Abducted in Plain Sight
Rotten Tomatoes rating: 88%
When Jan Broberg was 12, she asked her parents to let her go horseback riding with Robert Berchtold, their neighbour, a respected churchgoer and father of five. She didn’t return – Berchtold had drugged and kidnapped her and driven her to Mexico. Five weeks later, the FBI found Jan. That should be where this story ends. Instead, not only was Berchtold welcomed back into the family’s life, but he managed to abduct Jan a second time, only two years later.